Latest and Trending Topics

One Piece

Netflix’s “One Piece” – Navigating the High Seas of Live-Action Adaptation

The realm of live-action adaptations, whether from anime, manga, or video games, often carries an air of uncertainty. However, 2023 seems to be a remarkable year for this genre, defying past pitfalls. HBO’s “The Last of Us” and “The Super Mario Bros.” movie have set the stage with significant success, even if critical reception varies.

Netflix, with its penchant for taking calculated risks, has entered the arena with “One Piece,” a series adapted from Eiichiro Oda’s long-running manga. Netflix is no stranger to the unpredictable nature of such undertakings, having experienced both hits and misses, from the divisive “Death Note” to the short-lived “Cowboy Bebop.” With deep pockets and global reach, Netflix has the potential to reinvigorate “One Piece” for a vast and diverse audience. However, they also understand the challenges posed by passionate fans, cautious stakeholders, and the unique qualities of animation. Fortunately, the success of “The Last of Us” provides a glimmer of hope.

Netflix has taken careful steps to ensure the success of “One Piece.” Eiichiro Oda’s public endorsement of the project adds credibility, and showrunners Matt Owens and Steven Maeda have crafted an eight-episode season based on the first 100 manga chapters. Subscribers can dive into the vibrant world of “One Piece” with access to 15 seasons of the anime, building on the excitement generated at the Tudum fan event. While “One Piece” is poised for commercial triumph and aims to appease loyal fans, it grapples with the challenge of translating a two-dimensional world into live-action.

“One Piece” immerses viewers in a nautical fantasy where pirate crews chase a mythical treasure, concealed in the enigmatic “one piece,” while marines uphold law and order. Protagonist Monkey D. Luffy (played by IƱaki Godoy) dreams of becoming the Pirate King, assembling a diverse crew of dreamers, including swordmaster Roronoa Zoro (Mackenyu), cartographer Nami (Emily Rudd), chef Sanji (Taz Skyler), and the ever-enthusiastic Usopp (Jacob Romero Gibson). Luffy’s unique ability to stretch like rubber, acquired through the magical Gum Gum Fruit, adds a surreal touch to their adventures, where they encounter fishmen, snail phones, and even a shape-shifting clown (Jeff Ward).

The visual spectacle of “One Piece” is a deliberate fusion of CGI and practical effects, with meticulously choreographed combat sequences and epic moments that capture the manga’s grandeur. Yet, the transition to live-action can be jarring. Human-shark hybrids and other fantastical elements clash with reality, and the acting style, while exuberant, sometimes feels stiff, particularly when mimicking iconic manga poses. This raises a fundamental question: What does this adaptation offer that the original cannot?

“One Piece” echoes the dilemma faced by previous anime adaptations but also aligns with Netflix’s trend of reimagining intellectual properties like “Wednesday,” “The Witcher,” and “The Umbrella Academy.” These series are immensely popular and easy to binge-watch, though they sometimes lack true novelty. Nevertheless, “One Piece” aims not for novelty but for preservation, embodying the spirit of Luffy himself, who encourages unwavering pursuit of one’s goals.

In this ocean of adaptation challenges, “One Piece” on Netflix sets sail with both hope and caution, hoping to find the treasure of success while respecting its animated origins.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *